Is Lily Voldemort daughter?

[evilnuff]

No: HPFGUIDX 75539

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Shirley" <shirley2allie at h...> 
wrote:
> Me:
> But it doesn't go against canon.  Your reference above misquotes 
that 
> part of CoS.  DD says that V is the last *ancestor* to Slytherin.  
> That choice of wording (versus heir or descendent) gives a much 
> different meaning to the statement.  

I've wondered for a while if there's any possibility of current day 
characters at the end of the story travelling back in time and 
actually becoming some of the historic figures?  Example: we know 
Dumbledore has red hair, he also seems to know darn near everything 
that HRH know.  What if Dumbledore is in fact Ron who is all grown up 
and travelled back in time to become Dumbledore?  That would explain 
how he knows all sorts of things that happen around the trio.  It 
would also fit JKR's comment that one of the students becomes a 
teacher later on.  

What if some combination of Harry and co are actually Gryffendor
(Neville), Ravenclaw(Hermione), Hufflepuff(Luna?), and Slytherin
(Harry)?  Example: Lily could be V's daughter which would make Harry 
a descendant of Slytherin.  If at the end of book 7 Harry and co 
travel back in time and Harry becomes Slytherin then V would be 
Slytherin's ancestor as well?

I realize this is um...rather far-fetched but its just a thought. :)

-Nuff