Crouch Junior, which house?(was: Sirius a Slytherin?)

[lupinwolf2001]

No: HPFGUIDX 75579

> ***************
> Well, the Hat has told Harry that he was absolutelly sure of his 
> final decision, and that he never has been wrong. Also DD says that 
> what makes Harry a Gryffindor and not a Slytherin are his choices. 
> Do anyone know which house Crouch Junior was on? It is not 
> necessarily all Slytherins that are D Eaters, are they? the fact 
that 
> you are in Gryffindor doesn't make you a hero or a goody-two-shoes. 
> Look at Percy: prefect, head-boy, humungous big head. He is an 
idiot. 
> I hope he comes to his senses, but honestly, if he doesn't, he 
could 
> easilly become a greater idiot and a DE. Why not?
> Same for Peter, he doesn't actually fit in any house: he isn't 
> clever, brave, good or ambicious. He is a selfish "man", who fights 
> only for his own survival. I hope he does horribly.
> Nineve.

There is a theroy with some that Barty Crouch Jr. WASN'T actually 
guilty when he entered Azkaban... but the horrors of the place (and 
the association with the Lestranges changed him.) 

It is possible that he only became a servent of Voldemort after the 
fact. Partially due to the hatred his father showed him. (remember 
his biggest goal was that voldemort view his as "closer than a son".

That said, he very well COULD have been a gryphindore, for example, 
during school... but life changed his nature. 

Same thing COULD be said about Peter and others... Since Rowling 
tells us life is about choices not predetermination nor heritage, I 
can't beleive that she would be steadfast that a person can not 
change from the time that the hat sorts you (around 11 years of age) 
and into adulthood. Goodness knows I am not the same person by a long 
strech that i was at 11.

Unless the hat has powers that can predict the future, or else 
Rowling suggests that we ARE WHO WE ARE at 11, it is entirely 
possible for the hat to be "allways right" when sorting them at a 
young age and for that person to change in nature by adulthood.

Just a thought