What's the point of Houses?
ghinghapuss
rredordead at aol.com
Wed Aug 6 15:28:55 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 75657
> Hello.
> I am wondering why Hogwarts needs these different Houses to begin
> with. I mean, what is the point of sorting all the brave students
to > live in a dorm together, all the ambitious people together,
etc.?
> What does that accomplish? Everyone receives the same education
> anyway (different Houses have classes together). I understand that
> the students need to be placed in groups for the sake of
> organization, but why does that organization (i.e. Sorting) depend
on > their personality? Why can't the Hat just randomly select
students > for each House? A lot of bad will seems to crop up at
Hogwarts in > large part to the House system. Any thoughts?
> greatlit2003
Me:
It's pure British tradition and a very old fashioned one that still
exists at many schools today. Being British and having went through
a girls school that has Houses, I can explain that its used to create
loyalty, to encourage strong fraternity/sorority, promote
competition. As well as stimulating segregation and the need to
socialize 'only' with ones peers.
I remember well the feeling that my house was my home and the strong
loyalty and jubilation at winning the house cup at the end of the
year. Which we did twice while I was there. You see, I still feel
the need to tell you, a stranger, that bit of completely irrelevant
information. Who care if my house won twice, right? I still do.
Today in America I would equate it with employee brand loyalty. If
you work of a corporation like Coca Cola, (this is a hypothetical
example as I've never worked for Coca Cola) the company goes to great
lengths to ensure you, as an employee, feels as if you belong to
the 'family,' and that Pepsi is the 'enemy'. I'm sure those words are
not used but you get the idea. It helps to promote loyalty in its
employees to work towards a common goal with common allies and common
enemies.
I'm afraid this is not a good explanation but I'm sure there are many
better scholars out there that can explain what I'm trying to say
better.
Mandy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive