Petunia (suggestion why she hates magic)VERY LONGISH

spinelli372003 spinelli372003 at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 7 22:39:26 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 75967

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, 
> 
> bibphile: wrote 
>> (weren't their parents muggles like Hermione's?   

My question here is what are we basing the muggle theory on?  I have 
read and reread the books and no where have I found the sentence that 
Lily's parents were muggles.  The only thing close is in the first 
book when Petunia is talking and says, quoting her parents "Isn't it 
grand we have a witch in the family".  Doesn't say she is the only one, 
just that they have one.  Since there are no grandparents as yet and 
no other family how are we basing the fact that they are muggles?  
And has anyone seen anything to indicate that James was a 
pureblood ?  I wondered about his side of the family.  So hope this 
one goes through.  thanks
sherry






More information about the HPforGrownups archive