Tactics & Prescience
lunalovegoodrules
darkthirty at shaw.ca
Fri Aug 8 03:32:52 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 75987
> dan:
> That Dumbledore is famous for his defeat of the dark wizard
> Grindelwald is not because he's on a chocolate frog card, rather,
> he's on a chocolate frog card because he's famous, and he became
> famous by his deeds vs Grindelwald becoming known to everyone. In
the
> books, this being known to everyone has involved wizard papers. My
> point, however, was clearly that Dumbledore's defeat of Grindelwald
> might mean something in regards to Voldemort and Tom Riddle. How
did
> he defeat Grindelwald? Was it connected in some way to Riddle,
etc...
>
> Dan (a different one):
> I think it was connected to Hitler, if anything. Note that
Grindelwald was defeated the same year as the end of WWII (according
to the Lexicon, anyways), which is the same year the Riddle
graduates. Connection? Oh yes, oh yes.
Dan, I am fully with you on this, my very first post to the group
alluded to the association between the ww and the rw - the strength
of that connection regarding Grindelwald is the name itself, the year
of his defeat, obviously, and the fact that Harry knew this very
early on in his ww experiences. Also, Riddle's connection with
Grindelwald could have been around the time of the first opening of
the chamber, either before (he got help from Grindelwald or from
chessmaster dumbledore) or after... I assume before, of course. The
point is, the more I think about it, the more it becomes evident that
perhaps Dumbledore's defeat of Grindelwald in some way compromises
his relationship to Tom Riddle (and Lord Voldemort) and Harry Potter,
and maybe the current head of Slytherin :)
dan (PS Dan, use dan, not Dan, to identify me, or call me dan of BIC
LIGHTER)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive