[HPforGrownups] Aberforth Dumbledore and the shady side of WW

[Fred Uloth]

No: HPFGUIDX 76038

It seems that a lot of people have been speculating that Aberforth D. is 
the bartender at the hog's head. I agree that this is a valid theory as it 
would explain why Harry thought the bartender looked familiar. But Sirius 
tells the that "[Dung] was banned from the Hog's Head twenty years ago and 
that barman's got a long memory."

So here is my problem: Why would Mundungus have to wear a disguise if he 
and Aberforth are brothers in arms? The last OoP was probably start 20 
some-odd years ago and dissolved about 15 years ago after HP and LV first 
met. Both men were in the order and had met each other (at least they are 
both in Moody's photograph), so why would Aberforth continue this ban? I'm 
starting to think it may be somebody else....