Who did Bertha see kissing

[Zeynep Oner]

No: HPFGUIDX 76048

 "Diana Williams" <diana at slashcity.com> wrote

> The only problem with Snape being the person with
> Florence is that Bertha
> was several years older than Snape & the Marauders. 
> She looked "around
> sixteen" to Harry in the Pensieve scene, which would
> make Snape 13-14 years
> old at the time of the kiss with Florence. 

I write:

How do we know their age difference, did I miss
something? I don't think there was any reference to
any age differences. 

We know that Lucius is 41 now, making him 26 when
Harry and Draco was born; 9 years after Hogwarts
graduation. Assuming Harry was born right after his
parents' marrige, the Potters should be 18 when Harry
was born. So, assuming Snape was 13 when Bertha was
sixteen, that would make the Marauders also 13 and
Lucius 21, and not a student in Hogwarts. So it cannot
be Lucius Bertha saw. Of course, we don't know Harry
was born right after marriage, and we don't know Snape
was 13 when BErtha was 16, so we can only make wild
guesses about the identity of the Mystery Man.


__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software
http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com