Will Harry tell Ron & Hermione about the prophecy?

whimsyflower profwildflower at mindspring.com
Sun Aug 10 02:21:27 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 76328

lziner (post 76263), Buttercup (post 76272), mom31 (posts 76273 and 
76325), bboy_mn (post 76275), and jenny_ravenclaw (post 76297) 
~apologies if I've missed anyone!~ have all contributed to this thread.


me: 

I agree with mom31 that Harry might make an effort to protect H & R and 
Neville by not telling them about the prophecy,   Harry's always been a 
"loner," of the I-have-to-do-it-myself mold, but I think/hope one of the things 
he's learning is that he needs to rely more on others. I think part of his bristling 
at the "Hero" title is his knowing at some level that he needs to trust/depend 
on others more.   I understand part of the meaning of the "committee" who 
spoke with the Dursleys in the train station at the end of term was that Harry's 
not alone.

I also think Harry's decisions and his life in general will not "hang together" or 
make sense without knowing about the tremendous weight he's now carrying. 
I think Hermione is a keen enough observer to realize something has 
changed for Harry, and I believe she's curious and shrewd enough to make a 
good guess.  Failing a "good guess" I think she's not likely to let go of the 
question about why Harry is different until she has an answer that satisfies 
her.

Whimsy





More information about the HPforGrownups archive