Communicating with Sirius? (WAS: Portraits in Dumbledore's Office)

michelle_malfoy18 michelle_malfoy at hotmail.com
Sun Aug 10 03:58:12 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 76356

-casey- wrote:
> now i cried for days on end when Sirius died, but what I don't 
> understand is why we are all making theories and devising plans to 
> get Sirius to communicate with Harry again, when we could have been 
> doing this for Harry and James this whole time....

Good point, but I believe the reasoning behind this is as you pointed 
out we got to know Sirius, and so did Harry. You see Harry doesn't 
really remember(sp?) his parents; but when he met Sirius, Sirius 
became the embodiment of mother, father and godfather all in one. 
Sirius cared for Harry just as if Harry had been his own son. And 
Harry too cared for Sirius as he would have his father. So when 
Sirius died, Harry not only lost Sirius but every link he had to his 
reall family ( his parents). This magnified everything for our young 
heroine(sp?). It was as if he was re-living evrything all over again 
and at a really fragil stage in his life! 
 Hope, this clears up some of the confusion. This is what Sirius's 
death meant for me so it was only natural to me at least to see Harry 
reacting the way he did!

Michelle Malfoy






More information about the HPforGrownups archive