Magic Without Wands?
Liz
lizcrosssmith at yahoo.com
Sun Aug 10 15:40:21 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 76395
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Tamara" <buffyeton at y...>
wrote:
> Can wizards and witches do magic without their wands or a potion?
>
> Tamara
Clearly wizards and witches can do magic without wands. Before they
get wands -- in childhood -- they seem to spontaneously exhibit
magical "reactions" to situations that are stressful or emotional.
Hence the lifesaving magic, etc. that we have read about. I had
originally considered wands to be a tool that allows the witch or
wizard to "fine tune" or focus his or her magic. That would mean
that a wizard is capable of less precise, or less directed, or less
powerful magic without the wand. That would imply, however, that
intent and a certain amount of concentration would be necessary to
cast spells.
However, there are a couple things that seem to blow my theory. In
OoTP we at least hear Moody refer to the possibility of accidentally
blowing ones buttocks off. I can't imagine intent and concentration
on magic if you've got your wand in your back pocket. Secondly,
back in first year (Chapter 10 of SS/PS) Flitwick says, "And saying
the magic words is properly is very important, too -- never forget
Wizard Baruffio, who said 's' instead of 'f' and found himself on
the floor with a buffalo on his chest."
So, all that leaves me wondering what exactly is magic -- it appears
to be a power or energy the witch or wizard can summon and direct at
will, but it's a bit more tricky than that. If you've got to get
the wand movements -- "swish and flick" -- just right and you've got
to get the words just right -- "Wing-gar-dium Levi-o-sa, make
the 'gar' nice and long." -- then how do wizards invent/discover new
spells? Do you just say nonsense words and wave your wand around an
hope something happens? Is that what happened to Luna's mom?
I guess my question is: "What is the nature of magic?"
Liz
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive