Harry Potter names - tribute to Roald Dahl?
Wanda Sherratt
wsherratt3338 at rogers.com
Tue Aug 12 14:12:49 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 76696
My kids were watching the movie of 'James and the Giant Peach' this
morning, and I was struck by the name of the main character: James
Henry Trotter. Could "James and Harry Potter" possibly have been
named in tribute to Dahl? I've always thought of Harry's muggle
life as something straight out of one of Dahl's blackly comic
novels. His Christmas presents from the Dursleys - a toothpick one
year, and a tissue another - could have come straight out of "James
and the Giant Peach", where the poor little boy has to do all the
work and his vile aunts give him a boiled fish head for supper. As
a result, I could never get into the sombre discussions about the
sort of psychological effect Harry's upbringing would have on him,
or if he's suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Syndrome. His life
is just too farcical in its blackness. Yes, yes, I know that things
that bad and worse happen in real life, but this isn't real life.
It isn't even just a novel; it's a fairy-tale novel (or it was, in
the earlier books) and I feel sure that Rowling meant her
description of the Dursleys to be a black comedy, not a serious
expose about the things that go on behind the doors of neat suburban
houses.
Wanda
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive