James and Lily's Occupations
Trish
caitybugcreations at hotmail.com
Tue Aug 12 20:16:57 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 76801
> I have always wondered why Harry has not asked anyone what his
> parents did for a living. I would like to hear JKR's reason for
his
> lack of curiousity there. Since book four, I have thought the
> obvious - that the Potters were Aurors. But since everyone seems
to
> be so secretive about them, maybe James and/or Lily worked for the
> Department of Mysteries. If one or both of them were Unspeakables,
> maybe that explains why no one ever talks about J&L's careers - no
> one really knows what the Unspeakables actually do. Just a
thought..
>
> Brookeshanks
It has always bothered me that Harry does not ask ANY questions about
his family! I mean, you find out your a wizard and you meet all of
these people who knew your parents and you don't ask what they did
for a living? Do you have any aunts or uncles who are wizards?
cousins? Who were your grandparents? What happened to them? This
bothers me so so much in these books. I don't think Harry is so dim
as to not think about these things so why are they absent since JKR
must assume they would interest the reader (even if storyline
irrelevent, she does write a long book after all).
I alway had this theory that all (or at least some) of Harry's
answers are in "Hogwarts, A History" and that some day he is going to
listen to that darn Hermione and find out something really cool about
his mum (after all have you ever heard Harry tell Hermione his mum is
an Evans?) I just thought it would be a cute way to say that a clue
was under Harry's nose *all this time* and he never listened and just
read that silly book!
Trish.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive