Dumbledore's Age
angelberri56
pokeypokey at comcast.net
Tue Aug 12 23:52:15 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 76814
I'm sorry if this has already been said, but I checked the posts
and I couldn't find any threads.
I've been wondering alot about how old Dumbldore is. The
Lexicon states that he is around 150 years old. I find this hard to
believe. I don't think that anyone, even wizards, (and even
Dumbledore) could live that long, and still be healthy enough to
run a school, battle against LV, and so forth.
On what pretense did the Lexicon figure Dumbedore's age? Did
they just assume? It seems like they did, because I dont
remember any facts supporting this information- though I could
be wrong.
The Chocolate Frog Card says that Dumbeldore was famous for
the defeat of the dark wizard, Grindelwald, in 1945. Dumbledore
could quite possibly have been 30 something when this
happened-quite young. He is the most powerful wizard, afterall,
what's not to say that he wasn't powerful in his youth? Who says
he had to defeat him when he was much older? Besides, if you
look at the conversation between Umbridge and Professor
Marchbanks in OotP, chapter 31, it gives evidence that
Dumbledore was exceptionally talented in his years at Hogwarts:
"'No idea where he is, I suppose?" ...
"None at all," said Umbridge... "But i daresay the Ministry of
Magic will track him down soon enough...."
"I doubt it," shouted tiny Professor Marchbanks, "not if
Dumbledore doesn't want to be found! I should know....
Examined him personally in Transfiguration and Charms when
he did N.E.W.T.s... Did things with a wand I'd never seen
before..."'
Professor Marchbanks testing Dumbedore on N.E.W.T.s also
supports my theory- if she was old enough to test Dumbedore
when he was at Hogwarts, and Dumbledore is supposedly 150
years old, she must be even older! To me, this is ridiculous. I
dont think that anyone could live that long.
Also, some people think that Dumbledore borrowed some Elixir
of Life from his friend, Nicolas Flamel. But the stone was
destroyed in PS/SS... and Dumbledore said that once the stone
was destroyed, Nicolas and his wife would die. So if Dumbedore
was borrowing some Elixir, and the stone was destroyed, then
Dumbedore would have died, too. ( I also don't think that
Dumbeldore borrowed enough Elixir to last him a lot more
years...)
If anyone knows why the Lexicon would state that Dumbledore
was around 150, please tell me. I'm sorry this post skipped
around a lot, but I wanted to get all my thoughts in.
Thanks!
"angelberri56"
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive