SHIPs: Two "nots," no "shoulds"
sebfish5
redfish5 at onetel.com
Wed Aug 13 21:10:03 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 77020
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "occam6363" <pisola6363 at n...>
wrote:
> My SHIP cents: I have only two "nots," no "shoulds":
(snip)
> Harry is not going to end up with Hermione. That would leave Ron
as
> the odd man out, which makes no sense given the development of
> everyone's characters and the importance (so far) of the stability
of
> the Trio to the structure of the series. I don't think Ron's
> character supports a "loner" status. Harry of course might be best
> off as a loner (and perhaps will end up that way), given the
> heartache and the danger that's followed him around, which is why
I'm
> agnostic on Hermione/Ron. Hermione/Ron would break up the three-
way
> friendship dynamic, but I definitely think that Harry's love for
them
> would not at all be diminished if Hermione & Ron ended up a
couple --
> and vice versa. So I think we'd still have a stable Trio with
> Herminone/Ron, but not with Hermione/Harry.
>
> I'm rooting for Ginny -- JKR hasn't yet given any female character
> besides Ginny (not even Hermione) the experiences and the supreme
> self-confidence to match Harry's larger-than-life life. Gotta love
a
> girl who was able with perfect assurance to put Harry in his place
> when he was wallowing in all that misdirected angst over the
attack
> on Arthur Weasley.
>
> (I know this is sounding like OBHWF, but that's a by-product. And
I
> don't rule out Ron/Luna, see below.)
>
> Luna's cool, what a terrific character, definitely can't be ruled
out
> as a love interest for Harry or Ron. There's been evidence of
> chemistry between Harry and Luna AND Ron and Luna. She would be a
> kind of balm for Harry's troubled soul, and as an object of pity,
> perhaps perfect for Ron, who's got this huge protective urge
towards
> both Ginny and Hermione. She'd also be great for Ron because she
> seems quite capable of indulging in hero worship with Ron as the
> object.
(snip)
Good post occam, a sentiment I agree with. I would like to see Luna
as a potential romantic interest for any male character. I don't
think Harry/Luna would work but I would certainly not be suprised at
Luna/Ron or others. I think J.K. Rowling will neeed to pair off a
few people simply for...bear with me here...believability factor.
The idea that not one of Harry's mates found a partner (because it
would be obvious, wouldn't it, thats another interesting point)
is a little unbelivable though not totally so. So I expect a few
short-term casual pairings and maybe one long-term serious pairing
outside the main three.
In the main three, a one-day thing with a kiss will be a serious
matter because they are the central characters.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive