Umbridge's Great Success as a DADA Teacher

James Redmont jamesredmont at hotmail.com
Fri Aug 15 14:20:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 77333

> feetmadeofclay wrote:
 
> > English Common law requires that the justices be a self-
administered 
> > body distinguished from the legislative and the executive arms 
of 
> > government.  Fudge may repesent the excutive, Arthur's job may 
> > represent the legislative since we know he writes laws even if 
he 
> > doesn't pass them.  I get the feeling bureaucrats like Arthur 
write 
> > the laws, Fudge's team looks them over and they are sent 
directly to 
> > the Queen for official signing.

 "T.M. Sommers" <tms2 at m...> wrote:
> The Queen has nothing to do with wizarding law.  The decrees 
emanating 
> from the Ministry were signed by Fudge, not the Queen.  

Me:

Why is everybody talking about the Queen?  Who cares about her?  She 
doesn't have any power...I'd be more concerned with how the Prime 
Minister relates to all this (which T.M. Sommers did), if you wanted 
to related it to the British Ministry at all!  I know the PM knows 
about the WW, but it seems to me that the MoM spends most of its 
times making sure the rest of the muggle world *don't* know about 
the WW.  As far as making laws go, the British government has 
absolutely NOTHING to do with the MoM.  And the Queen?  Are you 
serious, feetmadeofclay???

James Redmont





More information about the HPforGrownups archive