Simple acronym for theory (was: Myrtle an Evans? )
Marci
blackgold101 at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 15 18:40:36 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 77390
MYRTLE: Maybe You're Related To Lily Evans
I wrote:
> Ok, maybe she has already served her purpose and there really is
> nothing more to her. But, what if there is more? A last name has
> not been given yet (has it?) so could Moaning Myrtle be an Evans?
> (Please correct me if I'm wrong and her last name has in fact been
> mentioned.) My crude timeline makes this possible, BUT ONLY IF
> Myrtle was a FIRST YEAR when she died in 1942-43. This would mean
> she was born in 1931. I feel that Petunia is 10 years older than
> Lily, so Myrtle could have been 10 or more years older than
Petunia.
> It could hold true that the Evanses did not have another child
until
> after the first one, Myrtle, died. Yet, this one did not receive a
> letter from Hogwarts. The youngest one, however, did. Could they
> have been so proud to have a witch in the family because the first
> one died? (Although, I don't know if you would be so happy as to
send
> you child to the same school where another one died years before.)
>
> Am I making any sense? What do you all think? There are a lot
> of 'flower' theories out there. People are also trying to connect
> Myrtle to the Blacks. I thought of connecting her to the Potters
> (dark hair and glasses) but she was muggle-born, as was Lily.
>
> Marci
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive