Ron's Development
scoutmom21113
navarro198 at hotmail.com
Fri Aug 15 22:22:10 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 77457
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "C M" <cmurph18 at y...> wrote:
> Reading through various posts in this group, I see a lot of
> statements being applied to Ron that are clearly considered by
many to be definitive truths about his character, i.e., that he's
> resentful of and/or angry about his brothers' accomplishments, his
> family's financial status, and his being "shunted to one side" in
his friendship with Harry. <snip>
> By the conclusion of OOP, however, it seemed to me that Ron had
> changed a great deal in ways that would combat those decidedly
> negative traits. He was more even-tempered (he was only briefly
> disappointed/irritated by Harry and Hermione missing the final
> Quidditch match), he was more confident (he helped win that match
by giving himself a mini pep talk) and no longer seemed so concerned
> with money (he didn't seem remotely affronted by Harry giving his
> Triwizard winnings to F&G).
>
> Am I alone in thinking that Ron has had some noticeably positive
> development? <snip>
> We won't know until then, but in the meantime
> I'll continue to contend that what we saw in Book 5 was a (slowly,
to some) maturing Ron who is well on his way to coming to terms with
who he is and where he fits in his family, his group of friends, and
the world as a whole. A Ron who, IMO, is becoming less and less
likely to envy his friends' achievements and/or turn traitor.
>
> CM
I agree that Ron has grown up alot. Even before though, his
comments struck me as "family" griping, but if anyone else made the
same kind of comments he would get upset. Most of the griping was
done to a member of his family or to Harry and in a private setting -
definately not in public. My impression is that even Hermione
didn't hear as much of it.
Example, I might complain about my kids not doing chores, homework,
etc. to family or friends (especially those who have kids the same
age), but never to people I don't know well.
Short of an imperious curse, I will be shocked if Ron turns
traitor. IMO it's not in his character. Friendship is so important
to Harry that traitor!Ron would be such a betrayal. I just don't see
JKR going that direction.
Ravenclaw Bookworm
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive