Harry/Voldemort showdown in 2 years

innovan innovan at broadviewnet.net
Sun Aug 17 14:00:33 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 77650

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ellejir" <eberte at v...> wrote:
> No one seems very 
> interested in preparing Harry for the final showdown.  
> Three of his 5 
> DADA teachers have been incompetent (and a fourth was an insane 
> DE...)  If the prophecy is true, the fate of the whole WW depends on 
> Harry defeating Voldemort.  If anyone needs to learn defense against 
> the dark arts, it is Harry.  Yet DD remains strangely unconcerned 
> about Harry's preparation.

Prophecies are difficult to read correctly except in hindsight. Harry 
defeated Voldemort in the first book of the series --was that 
fufilling the prophecy? What a fortunate coicidence, that HP fufills 
the prophecy in his first year at Hogworts and no more Voldemort ever 
again. Harry then defeated the Lord Voldemort diary in volume II --was 
that fufilling the prophecy --again?

The only thing the prophecy establishes conclusively is that DD, a 
wizard strong enough to effect the outcome of WWII, can't defeat Lord 
Voldemort for Harry this time. And if Love Conquers All, or at least 
Love Conquers Voldemort, Harry's hardly going to learn the Power of 
Love by grimly being reduced to an efficent Terminator-like killing 
machine. [Plus he'd become a one-dimensional bore]

--Innovan







More information about the HPforGrownups archive