Heartgrabbing moment

holly_phoenix_11 pentzouli at hotmail.com
Mon Aug 18 15:49:19 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 77804

>      Its in OOTP when Snape is reading Harry's mind and one of his 
> memories is when he was 9 (or something) and his heart was bursting 
> with jealousy watching Dudders ride his bike! :(! Any other moments 
> like that?
> 
> --Winky


My heartbreaking moments are these :
1) In PS : The time when Harry finds out the truth about the mirror 
of Erised. Total disilusionment...
2) In PoA : The scene where he watches himself opposite the lake, 
thinking it is his father.
3) In GoF : The scene where he is put on the grave and all the DEs 
are just chatting, while he can't react (I simply cannot imagine a 
fourteen-year-old in such a state...), as well as the moment when 
Wormtail cuts him to take his blood, as he realises what the Death 
Eaters and their evilness is all about. But what shook me the most in 
that book, was his desperation while he pretended to sleep in the 
hospital wing, when the others were chattering. He had all these 
people around him, but I think it was one of these moments when he 
felt really lonely.
4) In OoP : Well, after Sirius's death, the rest of the book was 
really heartbreaking. Not bad, but really heartbreaking. His grief 
for Sirius is very obvious, especially when he visits Hagrid but 
realises that he can't feel any more at ease. When he is with 
company, he wants to be alone, and when he is alone, he is 
overwhelmed with the feeling of loneliness. So sad...

holly_pheonix_11









More information about the HPforGrownups archive