Getting the secret out... PP instead of SB
meltowne
meltowne at yahoo.com
Mon Aug 18 18:24:20 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 77829
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "scoutmom21113"
<navarro198 at h...> wrote:
Me:
> Did PP give Serius a series of notes to give to the
> appropriate people telling them where J&L were hiding? If he
> didn't, how did they know where to find them?
Ravenclaw:
> Instead of re-posting I'll refer you to my post #77733. It was in
> response to Arya's post #77728. I think her post ties in with this
> post, especially the theory about Frank Longbottom (for those who
> are skipping around and missed that thread).
Me again:
Yes, I read that post. I'm not talking about how he told LV - I
agree LV probably made PP go with him; not necessarily to make sure
he got it right, but to force PP to witness James and Lily's
destruction.
What I wondor is how members of the order found out where they were.
I would assume they had 3 or 4 options before they cast the fidelius,
and then informed the secret keeper of that choice. Since the charm
was cast only shortly before they were killed, I would assume Harry
was directly protected by it, meaning that for Hagrid to rescue him,
Hagrid had to know the location. That, of course, means someone told
Hagrid where they were - yes, we know Dumbledore sent him, but since
Dumbledore was not the secret keeper, he couldn't have told Hagrid
where to go - just that he needed to go!
So this all begs the questions of how the order was informed of the
location, without anyone finding out that PP was the secret keeper
instead of SB. We know DD wrote out the location of Grimauld Place
to give the Harry, or he would not have been able to enter. Did PP
similarly write down the location of the hiding place, and then
deliver it to everyone else, giving the impression that SB sent him?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive