Is Umbridge a Half-Breed???

James Redmont jamesredmont at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 21 00:12:18 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 78212

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Laura Ingalls Huntley" 
<huntleyl at m...> wrote:

> James Redmont:
> >If Umbridge was raped, it would also have a sort of justice, like 
I 
> >said in my original post, if she had a half-breed child, since 
she 
> >loaths half-breeds so much.
> 
> You did NOT just say "rape" and "justice" in the same sentence. 
*scowls at you*  For shame.
> 
> Laura (who has rather strong feelings about sexual assault and 
doesn't believe that *anyone* -- under *any* circumstances -- 
deserves it.)

James Redmont:

For the love of god.  I was speaking of poetic justice, not legal 
justice.  Not the fact that she was raped, but if she had a *half 
breed child*.  I'm saying it's ironic, her prejudices came home to 
her.  Read the sentence again, come on, read it...If Umbridge was 
raped, IT WOULD ALSO HAVE A SORT OF JUSTICE, like I said in my 
original post, IF SHE HAD A HALF-BREED CHILD....

And anyway, I'll bet you thought I was a man, didn't you?

James "I'm a girl!" Redmont





More information about the HPforGrownups archive