[HPforGrownups] new thoughts after rereading SS/PS

Carolin Mönkemeyer shokoono at gmx.de
Thu Aug 21 20:50:04 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 78315

Stacy:

> The prophecy talks about voldemort marking harry, which I had always
> taken to mean the scar.  In the first book though, Dumbledore refers
> to Lily marking Harry with her love when she dies to save him.  In
> the fourth book, Voldemort takes some of Harry's own blood, so he
> can get the residing protection.  But it's almost like he's marking
> himself with something good, wherease Harry is good but marked with
> evil.  Like they compliment each other, and in a very strange way
> slowly becoming one.  In the fifth book, this trend continues, with
> Harry lapsing into Voldemorts thoughts, and at the end, with
> Voldemort possessing him.
>
> In book two, Harry himself points out how much he is like Tom
> Riddle.  Except where Tom is choosing evil, Harry is choosing good.
> Opposites.  And Harry shows mercy (book three, when he does not
> allow pettigrew to be killed) wherease Voldemort does not (his
> ditching Quirrel in book one).
>
> The problem with all these theories, is that I cannot tell where
> it's going.  Summarizing, Harry and Voldemort are seeming to become
> one creation, (I keep thinking of them like a Yin and Yang) but
> where do we go from here?
>
Me:
That's a good point!
Well where we could go from here could be (It's odd I know!) that two things
being its opposite neutralize each other. Relating to your theory: both are
becoming one so far they netralize each other... sticks to the prophecy...
but is verry nasty and bloody in my imagination, so I hope they're not.

Yours Finchen





More information about the HPforGrownups archive