Hermione's Hats
Robert Jones
jones.r.h.j at worldnet.att.net
Fri Aug 22 00:50:56 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 78347
I was looking at the picture of Dobby wearing all of Hermione's Hats
in the American version of OOTP, and a question occurred to me: how
do the students' clothes at Hogwarts get cleaned? Wouldn't the
house elves be picking them up and cleaning them all the time? (The
same would have been true for Dobby when he was with the Malfoys.)
The elves wouldn't be freed by doing this because their masters had
not directly handed them the clothing. But then how are the hats
and socks that Hermione is knitting and hiding around the Gryffindor
common room supposed to free them, since once again the elves would
only pick them up themselves? (Dobby said the elves were annoyed
and would not clean the Gryffindor common room, but was it just
because someone was trying to trick them? They weren't in any
danger of being freed.) JKR has made Hermione very brilliant, as
her analyses in OOTP repeatedly showed -- so wouldn't Hermione think
of this simple point too? What am I missing?
Robert Jones (aka Boris the Bewildered)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive