Ouroboros

[say543]

No: HPFGUIDX 78484

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "manawydan" <manawydan at n...> wrote:
> First thing I wonder about is that the time turner cabinet doesn't
seem to
> work that way - the DE that got in the way of it didn't physically
disappear
> back in time (not even his head...), just got younger.

hesdead-dealwithit(aka say543)
Actually, the DE fell into the bell jar, not the time turner cabinet -
that fell and shattered then picked itself up again then fell and
shattered . . . It is my opinion that there must be some sort of Time
Machine in the Time Room. We haven't gone throught all the doors nor
known what everything in the Time Room is. So your point is taken -
there is no time machine that would send someone back in time so far.
But we really do not know at all how anything in the time room works
or what it does, so whether or not there is some sort of machine that
sends someone back in time is not really up for argument right now -
it is impossible to know whether or not there is one.

> Second thing I wonder about is, given the physical changes that have
> happened to Voldemort, by what means he would have become a close
friend of
> Godric Gryffindor before the Founding? doesn't say much for Godric's
taste
> in friends!

hesdead-dealwithit:
Well, I think it's kind of shady that Godric and Salazar friends in
the first place! I'm confident that if Salazar/LV tried to become his
friend, he could. Plus, as one of the most pwerful wizards of all
time, Salazar/LV would naturally be one of the founders, and it makes
sense that he would be more of Slytherin's friend that Rowena's or
Helga's.

Any other ideas from anyone else? Any holes you can punch through it?
Post 'em!

hesdead-dealwithit