[HPforGrownups] Weird Sisters - music

manawydan manawydan at ntlworld.com
Sun Aug 24 18:10:54 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 78601

Wanda
>The Weird Sisters make me wonder what else the WW does for music.
>And what about people who don't like modern music?  Do wizards like
>Bach and Mozart?  (I can't see why not.)  And do they have some way
>of listening to music, as Muggles have recordings?  It's funny that
>you never hear about Hogwarts students listening to music, when it's
>one of the most common interests of Muggle children that age.  I'd
>think that students who grew up in Muggle families would really miss
>familiar music once they get to Hogwarts.  Or is that sort of thing
>replaced by something more wizardish?  There must be *something* -
>doesn't Dumbledore say in his first speech at Hogwarts that music is
>the greatest magic of all?

I wonder if the key to the WW and music is that they _make_ music rather
than just consuming it, as we did in our world before the advent of
radio/TV/video/MTV and all that stuff.

Or possibly that they are going that way. There is a radio station which
broadcasts music, there are the Weird Sisters, there is even Stubby Boardman
(if you believe that that's a real person). Conversely, there's never any
mention of music going on in any of the pubs, not even in the Leaky Cauldron
when Harry was staying there in PoA: you'd think they'd have a piano in the
corner or a session going on or _something_

Cheers

Ffred

O Benryn wleth hyd Luch Reon
Cymru yn unfryd gerhyd Wrion
Gwret dy Cymry yghymeiri





More information about the HPforGrownups archive