Heliopaths

[bohcoo]

No: HPFGUIDX 78782

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "say543" 
<hesdead_dealwithit at h...> wrote:
> Luna has much much more to show us.
> > 
> > Bohcoo
> 
> That's the only part that I agree with you - she does have much more
> to show us.
> 
> But DD said "there is one room that is kept locked at all times."
> Wouldn't he have said "One of the rooms that is kept locked at all
> times. . . " if there was more than one? Everything that he said was
> meant to imply that there was ONE room. Plus, if there is one locked
> room, and Harry and Co. find a locked room, what is the chance that
> THAT room that they found is NOT the one mentioned?





Bohcoo again:
Actually, what Dumbledore said was, "There is a room at the 
Department of Mysteries that is kept locked at all times..." (pg. 843)

He did not say, "There is ONE room. . ." If he had, your 
interpretation of his comments would be accurate.

By saying, "there is a room," he is not even implying that it is the 
ONLY locked room, IMHO. My take on it was that Dumbledore was simply 
referring to one of the locked rooms, one among possibly several. The 
room Dumbledore was talking about had nothing whatsoever to do with 
the door that melted Harry's knife. 

Bohcoo