generational parallels / Heir of Hufflepuff
phluxist
phluxist at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 26 07:28:56 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 78805
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Carla Borsoi" wrote:
(cut)
I find it lacking that we would not have heirs for both Hufflepuff
and Ravenclaw.
The reason this nags at me is that we hear the new S-hat song at the
beginning of OOTP and it bespeaks the need for the four houses to re-
unite. I don't believe it is possible to re-emerge with a common
goal (originally to educate wizards) solely on the basis of two
representatives in the current era for this to be true.
If so, who would these representatives be? I think that Luna is a
good start for Ravenclaw- she was brought in a much more well-formed
character than other students we've met over the past couple years
and has definitely played a role that is more than window dressing.
I'm struggling with a Hufflepuff, Justin and Ernie don't work and I
feel like we need the m/f balance that we see in original four (2
men, 2 women). So, out of the characters we've met that would leave
Susan Bones and Hannah Abbott as some of the more well-realized ones.
(cut)
.....
Me:
Now, I know that the films and the books are different, but it is
widely known that JK does work with the screenwriter for each new
film. And although she has said that she doesn't give info to him
readily, she has admitted that he, perhaps, knows more about the
future of the series and characters than anyone else.
With that said, has anyone noticed that the girl that plays Susan
Bones is ALL OVER the first two movies. She's never addressed much,
but she's always there in the background. Possibly this might be
because the actress is actually Chris Columbus' daughter. Although,
she could have easily been cast as Susan Bones AFTER the screenplay )
including extra assignments) was finished.
JK has said some interesting stuff in the DVD interviews from the
films. Notably, that book 6 has an important relevance with a
seemingly insignigicant element in the film version of CoS. I
wouldn't be surprised if JK has also encouraged certain *lesser*
characters to appear more often than not in the background shots of
the films.
-Phlux
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive