[HPforGrownups] Re: Time travel

[Carolina]

No: HPFGUIDX 78810


> Simariel wrote:
> I thought that before reading Talisman's post, 78370. She has
> reversed your argument, that Harry survives because he
> survives.

> Melanie
> Very interesting post ... so is she arguing that someone else
> saved Harry in PoA? Sorry for being thick.

Ups, not at all, it comes from a line of Talisman in the same 
thread, I have never got a problem with Yahoo search if I know the 
tittle, try copy and paste the whole tittle of the post and it will 
eventually appear.  "POA Dementor Kiss on Harry - New Question"

She is stating that Snape saved Harry, who else could. Someone (I 
can't find the other thread) recalled Harry seeing Snape's face 
during a Dementor&Oclumency scene in OoP, that it could be a memory 
(the shadow of a memory).

I think Snape was not so badly injured in the Shrieking Shack.

silmariel