Prophecy Contradiction

[entropymail]

No: HPFGUIDX 79010

Sevvie "severusbook4" here:
> If this was true, wouldn't everyone just jump poor old Fawkes and 
> pluck him bald?  So all the good guys could have phoenix feather 
> wands?  I think the wands still work but the fact that the beams 
> came in contact is where the trouble started with the similar core 
> materials.  And Harry did use his force of will to push LV's AK back 
> into his wand, and that is when the spell regurgitation thing took 
> place. If either beam would have struck home, then the requested 
> result would have happened, unless Harry did the boy who lived thing 
> again. Just my opinion.  But I think, if this is true, Fawkes better 
> start watching his tail feathers. >>>


My turn:

Love the visual of plucking Fawkes bald, Sev, but there must be some
reason they can't do this; some pre-ordained plucking statute or
something. 

But, just because the two wands can't duel with each other, doesn't
really mean that Harry and Voldemort can't duel.  Harry could get
another wand (when Ron's wand is damaged, McGonagall tells him it
"needs to be replaced"), although I doubt that this would happen, as
too much importance has been put on the fact that Harry was meant to
have this particular wand in Ollivander's.  Or, he could use someone
else's wand to duel.  Or, of course, he could just sneak up on Voldie
from behind and hit him with a zap or two when he least expects it. 
No duel required.  

"entropymail"