Prophecy Contradiction

[severusbook4]

No: HPFGUIDX 79071

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, jazmyn <jazmyn at p...> wrote:
> 
> happyduck1979 wrote:
> > Emma "punkstarz85" wrote:
> >  > The Prophecy states something along the line of Harry or 
Voldemort
> >  > must murder the other for the remaining to live. However 
unless I'm
> >  > forgetting something, in order to do so, they must duel. I 
can't
> >  > see either going silently or unwillingly, can you?
> >  >
> >  > I'm curious to see how J.K Rowling is going to work around 
this!
> 
> Rachel: 
> > There is nothing to work around.  Wizards do not need to duel to 
kill
> > each other... one can sneak up behind the other or take him or 
her by
> > surprise.  More than this, wands battling in my mind means that
> > both spells need to be cast at precisely the same moment.  Thus 
they
> > meet in midair and the effect takes place.  There is also the
> > possibility that one of the two might at some point need to use a
> > wand not their own. >>>
> 
> 
> Like Avatar and Black Wolf in the movie Wizards.  Avatar pulled 
out a 
> gun and shot Black Wolf, when everyone thought they would duel it 
out 
> magically.  What WOULD Voldemort do if Harry pulled out a gun and 
blew 
> his head off?  A trigger can be pulled faster then one can say a 
spell...
> 
> I think if JKR pulled that stunt in the books, Ralph Bakshi would 
sue 
> her and her fans would gang up on her and silly string her till 
she 
> resembles a rainbow haystack.
> 
> If Volde falls off a cliff, then Disney might sue.. Last minute 
> 'conversion to good' would be too Darth Vader'ish.
> 
> Its going to be near impossible to find a way to kill Voldemort 
off and 
> be original, you know...
> 
> Jazmyn

I think it will end up very similar to the first confrontation the 
two already had.  We will see that actual battle between them, Harry 
will be beat and LV will be standing over him, and utter AK, the 
green energy will hit HP and then we will see what hurt LV in the 
beginning.  HP will glow with some enternal force and destroy LV, 
but this time LV is completely mortal, and will die for good.  Harry 
will be unconscious, and DD or Snape will pick him up and carry him 
off, as the boy who lived again.  And I think Harry will be beat 
mentally, he will see one of his friends go down, maybe Ron, or 
Hermione, or Ginny, but they will not be dead, Harry will think that 
though.  Just my thoughts.

Severus