Lily's Eyes (Secret Garden similarities)

brightlywoven brightlywoven at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 28 20:08:35 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79125


 --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "princesspeaette" 
wrote:

 > >This is really random, and probably has nothing to do with 
Harry, 
 > >but I just thought I might put it out there.... 
 > > 
 > >I was reading a post about Lily's eyes, and a thought just 
popped 
 > >into my head. In "The Secret Garden", which is a musical, and 
 > >also a book, there's a song called "Lily's Eyes"... It goes 
 > >something like...
 > 
> >Anyway... it's talking about two characters- Colin and Lily. The 
> >song is about how Colin has his (dead) mother's eyes. 
 
And Margaret replied:

 > It's really weird you should mention this, I posted the same 
 thought 
 > on Sunday in message #78672.  But the song's not about Colin, 
it's  about Mary.  It's when Neville Craven reveals he was also in 
love 
 > with his brother Archibald's wife, Lily loved Archibald even 
though 
 > Neville could not understand why,  and how Mary has Lily's eyes.
 > 
 > I'm working on a FILK :-)  (assuming I can find a sound clip to 
 post)
 > ~Margaret


My (Brightly Woven's) reply:

What a great catch everyone.  The tone of the musical is very Harry 
Potter, I think, with ghosts creeping around everywhere and such.

One additional detail, although the song _is_ about Mary, the niece, 
in the book it is the son, Colin, who has his dead mother's eyes.  

Looking forward to your filk, Margaret.  It's always great to read 
them, especially when one knows the tune and can sing along (i Keep 
thinking I should get a copy of _1776_ so that I can enjoy those 
filks!!).

Brightly Woven (a lurker and newbie poster)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive