Re: Where Snape belongs on the family tree

[Cindy]

No: HPFGUIDX 79153

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "princesspeaette" 
<princesspeaette at y...> wrote:
> Cindy:
> >If all pureblood families are interrelated, it is very possible 
that 
> >Severus is somehow related to the Malfoy's. I really believe that 
> >Severus and Phineas are closely related. They look the same, 
behave 
> >the same and use the exact same language and words, phrases and 
> >tones.
> >I also think that it is very possible that the man with sallow-
skin 
> >in St Mungo's could be Severus's father, and that Severus might 
have 
> >even caused the irreversible spell damage - perhaps whilst 
> >protecting him self, or his mother. 
> > all Severus fans visit http://www.designerpotions.com/ss
> 
> <snipped>
> 
> 
> 
> 
> I really like the theory that Snape and Phineas are related, I'm 
very 
> fond of both of them.  The only thing I don't like about it is that 
> it would mean Snape was related to Sirius, and I don't like Sirius.
> 
> 
> The sallow skinned man on the closed ward is probably not Snape's 
> father, since it was Broderick Bode, the man who tried to get into 
> the DOM.
> 
> (OoP pg 511 US hardcover)
> "A sallow-skinned, mournful-looking wizard lay in the bed opposite, 
> staring at the ceiling; he was mumbling to himself and seemed quite 
> unaware of anything around him."
> 
> (Oop pg 512 US hardcover)
> "And look Broderick, you've been sent a potted plant and a lovely 
> calander with a different fancy hippogriff for each month, they'll 
> brighten things up, won't they?" said the Healer, bustling along to 
> the mumbling man.
> 
> 
> ~Margaret

Cindy replies:

Oh! You are completely right about the mumbling man! Thanks for 
pointing that out, I can't believe I missed it. (Then again it was 
about 3 in the morning at the time, so I forgive myself).
I am also very fond of both Severus and Phineas, and I also loathe 
Black. 
If all the pureblood families are interrelated, i'm afraid there is 
no escape for Severus - somewhere along the line he must be related 
to the Blacks. But I wonder how far away from the Malfoy's he is, 
seeing as him and Lucius are so close.

-Cindy