Dumbledore's 'Plan' for Harry
njelliot2003
nelliot at ozemail.com.au
Fri Aug 29 14:17:19 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 79194
In the chapter The Lost Prophesy of OoP, Dumbledore tells Harry
about his plan for him. But what is the plan? The only plan I heard
was to save Harry's life by using the blood link/charm of his Aunt
Petunia. That part of the plan succeeds - "Five years ago, then ....
you arrived at Hogwars, neither as happy nor as well-nourished as I
wold have liked, perhaps, yet alive and healthy. You were not a
pampered little prince, but as normal a boy as I could have hoped
under the circumstance. Thus far, my plan was working well." (OoP
pg. 737, last para, au. ed.)
But after that I couldn't work out what the rest of DD's plan for
Harry entails.
And what is the 'flaw' in the plan? Dumbledore said that the flaw
was delaying the revealation of why big V wanted to kill him. His
reason for staying mum was to save Harry from the great burden it
would place on him. DD's weakness was that he grew to love Harry and
wanted to spare him further pain. But how does Harry knowing about
the prophesy change the plan?
As DD knew, Harry now has an *enormous* burden on his shoulders (as
if he hasn't suffered enough!) but I don't see how this affects DD's
plan.
If this has been discussed before, could someone please point me to
a relevant message?
Nicholas who-thinks-there-must-be-more-to-the-plan-but-either-DD/JKR-
doesn't-want-to-give-it-away-yet-or-he-missed-something Elliot
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive