Umbridge????

[vecseytj]

No: HPFGUIDX 79222

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "slgazit" <slgazit at s...> wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Tonya Minton" <tminton at d...> 
> wrote:
~snip~
> I personally don't believe she was raped. For two reasons: I can't
> imagine any woman writer, especially one as sensitive as JKR,
> using rape as a punishment, even towards such a disgusting
> character. The second reason is the nurse's
> assertion that there was nothing wrong with her except for shock.
> She would not have said so if Umbridge was raped.
> 
> Umbridge was in shock at being manhandled and held captive by
> a group of creatures she considered sub-humans at best, not to
> mention needing rescue from the person she supposedly replaced.
> I think this is a very fitting punishment for her.
> 
> Salit
 
Hi Salit~  I have been thinking about this post and responded to one
of the early posts about Umbridge, and thinking that she had been,
(only because being a greek myths buff... I have read about Centaurs
for ages).. and having said that, getting drunk and raping women was
at the top of their list of fun activities. 

But, what if she *wasn't* raped.  What if they gave her some wine, and
she got real *friendly* with them!  Hummm?   Yes, little miss hater of
half breeds, getting all lovie dovie over a half horse, half man? 
Hummm, what if the reason DD brought Umbridge out so with such ease
was 'cause the Centaurs wanted her *gone*.  She was throwing herself
at all of good looking Centaurs and they were afraid she was gonna
attack them? <g> .. I know silly, but, still something I havent' seen
posted.

Tj