Dumbledore's 'Plan' for Harry
hermionegallo
hermionegallo at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 29 23:12:25 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 79269
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "njelliot2003" <nelliot at o...>
wrote:
> In the chapter The Lost Prophesy of OoP, Dumbledore tells Harry
> about his plan for him. But what is the plan? The only plan I heard
> was to save Harry's life by using the blood link/charm of his Aunt
> Petunia. That part of the plan succeeds...but after that I couldn't
work out what the rest of DD's plan for Harry entails.
>
>> Nicholas who-thinks-there-must-be-more-to-the-plan-but-either-
DD/JKR-
> doesn't-want-to-give-it-away-yet-or-he-missed-something Elliot
That's the big one bugging me, too. I've been wondering if the plan
was to keep Harry alive long enough to learn all he'd need to learn
to be able to fight Voldemort to the death; what if Dumbledore
interpreted the prophecy to mean that they'd both die? If that was
the case, then loving Harry too much would certainly qualify as
interference. How icky, I know, but Dumbledore does say that he
caught himself caring more for Harry's present happiness more than
the tremendous number of faceless and nameless lives that were at
stake... That could indicate that his plan was to sacrifice one life
in exchange for many many lives.
I'm also wondering if there's still not enough information for us to
determine what the plan was.
hg
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive