Is Agnes Snape's Mother? (WAS: some points in OOP)
Angel Moules
angelofthenorth at cantab.net
Tue Dec 2 13:14:42 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 86305
sunnylove0 at a... wrote:<snip>> 2) Agnes, the lady in St. Mungo's, who is
told by the healer that> her son is > dropping by that night, and in the
very next chapter Snape is in his> good > traveling cloak and repeatedly
says he has somewhere else to be (of> course it > could be wanting to
get away from Sirius or a DE meeting, but....)
************
I think this works. My own suspicion though, is based on the fact
that when someone knows something they oughtn't - like Harry knowing
about the Pensieve - they get blanked. When Snape holds a mere grudge,
then he's a nasty piece of work.
Which brings me to this.
The man in the pensieve, is Snape's father, and for this hypothesis,
I'm saying he's a DE. I suspect that his mother is innocent, and the
potions whizzkid.
The Longbottoms raid the Snape house, while Agnes is brewing, and
arrest Snape Senior. Agnes' work is interrupted, and we find that we
have something of a 'Fire and the Rose' situation. She is rendered
into a dog. Which makes me wonder if part of the reason for the
Longbottom's madness is revenge for an injury inflicted on one of
their own, who happened to be innocent
Angel wanders off, wondering whether JKR has been to Burton Agnes
Hall, where one of the ghosts is the grey lady. Burton Agnes is the
only village in England, where the name of the village derives from
a personal first name, rather than that of a saint of the local
church.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive