The Room of Requirement is the Chamber Pot Room?

Diana dianasdolls at yahoo.com
Wed Dec 3 15:44:41 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 86401

Geoff wrote:
> (Just in passing, Hermione uncharacteristically gets some facts 
> wrong. It wasn't Dobby who lost Harry the bones in his arm - it 
was Lockhart)

Diana writes:

I don't think Hermione got the facts wrong, I think she just 
compressed some details for the purpose of speediness in warning 
Harry about trusting Dobby's judgement.

Don't forget, Dobby is the one who bewitched the bludger to chase 
after Harry in CoS.  And that same bludger was responsible for 
breaking Harry's arm, resulting in his unfortunate bone-removing 
treatment by the incompetent Lockhart.   

While Lockhart was the one who actually removed Harry's bones, that 
event wouldn't have happened at all if it weren't for Dobby 
bewitching that bludger in the first place.  

Diana L.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive