The Room of Requirement is the Chamber Pot Room?

[Geoff Bannister]

No: HPFGUIDX 86420

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, liz <liz at s...> wrote:


> Liz:
> 
> Just to be annoyingly nit-picky and to defend the lovely Hermione, 
she's not
> actually wrong. Dobby jinxed the rogue bludger that broke Harry's 
arm, which
> Lockhart then brilliantly de-boned. Dobby is definitely tangentially
> responsible for Harry losing his bones. I think Hermione is just 
being
> economical with her words and pointing out the unhappy result of 
Dobby's
> plan, rather than describing the entire process.
> 
> Hermione is never wrong!!!! :)


Geoff:
Don't agree, I'm afraid.

If Lockhart hadn't been such a self-centred and arrogant berk and had 
listened to those who told him to let Harry go to Madam Pomfrey, the 
whole incident wouldn't have happened.

You might just as well say that if somebody drops a glass of water 
and spills it that it is also the fault of the person who filled the 
glass.....

Knowing HG's pro-elf tendencies, I'm surprised she even suggested he 
was to blame. <g>

Geoff