[HPforGrownups] It's A Wonderful Life? (was re: Overturning the prophecy)

[Samantha Hilsenrod]

No: HPFGUIDX 86680

Nothing is too wild in these books.  But I don't think
that would happen because it would reverse too much
and make too much difference in what could be, if youu get
what I'm saying?  

I think that's why they don't use the
time turner to reverse things like the Potter's death
and what they thought Sirius had done.  There are too
many possible repercussions if you change what was
meant to be, and what the characters would choose. 
You could upset the fabric of time.  DBD is wise and
he would realize it.  

Why, do you ask then, did they
allow Hermionie to travel back in time to get to her
classes?  Because it was a trivial matter and not
really affecting the big picture.  Also, saving Sirius
and Buckbeak just happened that night not very big not
having possible huge reprucussions (Buckbeak is just a
hippogriff and actually they got to Black just in time
so they only really changed Buckbeak's fate directly
by going back in time,  Black was sort of indirect I
think (they got there just in time with Buckbeak who
they had saved directly) so Black didn't count.  

Maybe I'm biased because I am so in love with Sirius.  I
think he is so sexy and if I could would go into the
fifth book (before he dies) and chain him to a bed, I
love his Byronic heroness (okay going off on a tangent
I will stop now.)

"Samantha"