Sexual Temptaion was: Stereotyping

arrowsmithbt arrowsmithbt at btconnect.com
Mon Dec 8 20:18:01 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 86739

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ghinghapuss" <rredordead at a...> wrote:
> 
> Kneasy brought up the point of the lack of Temptation in the HP saga 
> and I agree with him.  Did any one else notice how Harry was 
> inexplicibly drawn to pictures of Bellatrix whenever he saw one?  I 
> though it was interesting. Now she is on his s**t list because of the 
> incident with Sirius, but why introduce such a powerfully sexual 
> woman (Am I projecting here?  Is it only me who sees her as overtly 
> sexual?  I know it's not canon but there is something about 
> Bellatrix...) and not use her.  Can we expect to see the sexual 
> seduction of Harry by Bellatrix?  I would love to see him stuggle 
> with that one: "What should I do? AK her now....or kiss her first?" 
>

Kneasy (sweating slightly):
Yes please! 
Not quite the sort of temptation I had in mind, but who cares?
I've always been firmly of the opinion that what every 17 y.o. boy
really needs is Tina Turner. And Bella is about the closest Harry
is going to get.  Impressionable young lad that he is, he wouldn't
stand a chance. A lamb to the slaughter.

I've often moaned about the lack of a femme fatale, too. This could
get very, very interesting. 

Mandy:
> If not Bellatrix, what about the new DADA teacher?  I've been 
> expecting the arrival of a young, beautiful female teacher for the 
> last 2 books.  The kind of teacher all the boys fall in love with and 
> fantasize about. Kind of like the stereotype of the sexy French 
> Language mistress.  After all the girls had Lockheart in CoS and we 
> all know boys are a couple of years behind the girls in the whole sex 
> thing anyway, so it's my desire to see a sexy female professor, 
> secretly working for LV who's sent to Hogwarts with the goal of 
> seducing the kids (boys and girls) over to the dark side and become 
> DE's.
> 

Kneasy:
These are plot lines that I can live with. I may well write to JKR with
suggestions and a plea that the next book have an illustrated edition.

More seriously though, she was  very good at the basic ineptitude of 
young males starting out on life's rich tapestry  in GoF. It would set up
some nice tensions too, but I  doubt she would do more than hint at
the potential for mass mayhem. Flitwick  would have spasms  and
McGonagall would have kittens. How would  DD deal with this? Dose
the pumpkin juice, presumably.

However, a hormonal dilemma over Bella could be a serious possibility.       






More information about the HPforGrownups archive