Fidelius swap was Re: The Sorting Hat

[ghinghapuss]

No: HPFGUIDX 87522

> Berit replies:
 So I really believe Sirius would have been willing to die for his 
friends, refusing to betray them, even if he had family of his own. 
Just like Lupin and James would have done for him. That's the beauty 
of loyalty, bravery and friendship :-) The principle of true love in 
its most extreme 

Mandy here:
Only for the brief time at the end of PoA would Sirius really have 
died for James.  Hind sight is alway 20/20.  Before then.  Absolutly 
not, and Sirius knew that about himself. He proved it by turning down 
the job of Secret Keeper.  He knew that under LV pressure he would 
break and give away the Potter secret before he died.

Mandy