Harry in NEWT Potions Class? (Was: Is Snape confident?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 87656

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mom31" <mom31 at r...> wrote:
> 
>   Ces said:
> 
>   I have to totally disagree with you on that point...it was Snape 
>   who was the wronged one in SS because Harry decided his guilt 
with 
>   little evidence and then never apologized to Snape for thinking 
he 
>   was the one trying to kill him.  Harry owed Snape at least a 
thank 
>   you for saving his life at Quiddich.
> 

We do remember, right, how "friendly" Snape was to Harry at the first 
Potions lesson?
Small wonder Harry considered him to be a villain, which is a 
perfectly normal thing for eleven year old to do.

Thank you for saving his life at Quidditch? First of all I would say 
for attempt to save his life - I think Hermione was the one who 
actually did it. nevertheless, attempt still counts as a good 
deed. :o)

I'll say Harry still has time to do it.


> 
>   Joj:   
>   How exactly was Snape hurt by Harry thinking Snape was trying to 
kill him?  Except for the pensive, Harry has never hurt Snape.  Snape 
hurts Harry all the time.  Why would Harry thank Snape, the man who 
goes out of his way to make his life a living hell, and would do 
worse if he could get away with it?  Snape would laugh in his face, 
or deny it, or hate him even more.  Why should Harry?
> 

I also think that Harry never actually hurt Snape (even when he went 
into Pensieve, which was a wrong thing to do, of course. remember 
that he was looking for information about Department of Mysteries, 
not to learn something about Snape's past. Under circumstances - 
being kept in the dark all year and going crazy about it, I can't say 
that I blame him much)

 
Alla