Just suppose Snape is the heart of it all

a_silmariel silmariel at telefonica.net
Tue Dec 30 14:59:56 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 87778


Kneasy wrote:
 
> No, what depresses me is that I can't see any way to eliminate any
of the
> alternative explanations as to what's going on with the Prophecy
until we 
> get more information. 

> Not even a smidgeon of confirmation of the contents when the globe broke
> in the Ministry. By some strange(!) chance not a single word of the
Prophecy
> was heard. 
 
> It's things like this that raise my paranoia index to unhealthy levels.
> I feel that I'm being messed about and I'm not happy.

I've decided to retreat of the realm of prophecies, they are a mortal
trap and I haven't seen yet the Dark Lord raising more powerful than
before.

But count me on the paranoic side. Instead of building a mistery and
revealing it later, she throws a murder at the end of the novel,
letting me with the question of who killed Sirius and why.

And just suposse the heart of it all is a literal heart, the heart of
a dragon, how she could laugh later given she has 'Draco Dormiens...'
in every novel, rigth in front of us. It would be circular if the
heart is from Norbert, linking 1 and 7 books both in the present and
the past (if she writes about Godric's Hollow in book 7).

silmariel













More information about the HPforGrownups archive