Who has the map?
gkjpo <kristen@sanderson-web.com>
kristen at sanderson-web.com
Sat Feb 1 19:02:36 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 51377
I have been re-reading GoF lately and it made me stop and think. I
don't believe anyone mentioned this after Barty's confession in the
book, so who went and picked up the Marauders Map from Fake!Moody's
office?
Was it:
a. Dumbledore? He was surprised by its existence, so he may have
made a point to go get it.
b. Harry? He could have made his way over to Moody's office and
snagged it back.
c. Snape? Always a possibility, and if it did play a part in The
Prank as some have suggested, he would be extra curious about it.
d. McGonnagal? She was present when it was mentioned, but I think
she's least likely to have gone to get it.
e. Winky? She was probably too busy bemoaning Barty's (jr and sr)
demise.
f. Real!Moody? If Dumbledore told him about what happened, he may
have gotten the map.
g. Anyone else?
I think I vote for f. We know that Real!Moody is in OotP and it
would be interesting if he were able to help by providing this
important information.
I amost added Rita Skeeter. It's possible that she overheard Barty's
confession too (did Moody have a window office?), but I can't believe
there's any benefit in her having it.
Kristen - sorry if this was discussed before
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive