The Imperio Curse
    vojoca <vojoca@yahoo.com> 
    vojoca at yahoo.com
       
    Mon Feb  3 12:51:13 UTC 2003
    
    
  
No: HPFGUIDX 51525
Grey Wolf wrote:
> I very much doubt that there are other spells that have the same 
effect 
> as the Imperio, for two reasons. The first one, what would be the 
point 
> of duplicating the spell? There is no aparent reason *not* to use 
the 
> Imperio (except for the moral reasons, of course, and any other 
mind 
> controlling spell would suffer from the same problem), and the 
second 
> is that we *know* that the only three unforgivable curses are 
Imperio, 
> AK and Cruciatus. If there was some other mind control spell 
around, it 
> would be listed as unforgivable too, don't you think?
> 
and now me:
Just to clear up something that you may have misunderstood.  I wasn't 
asking if there were any other *spells* specifically.  I was asking 
if there were any other *ways* to put someone under your control i.e. 
the veritaserum, where the effect is you can't help but answer 
questions with the truth even if you don't want to, and as cbca1126 
(thanks, btw) pointed out, Tom Riddle managed to get Ginny under his 
control in CoS and he did so without a wand or body.  (Which now 
makes me curious...how *did* Riddle do that?)
I completely agree with you that there is no need to duplicate a 
spell.  It would be kind of...well, stupid, really, wouldn't it?  
so, ARE there any other possible ways to go about controlling 
someone's mind/actions?  (Besides the ones already mentioned.)
vojoca
    
    
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive