Hermione's origins
David <dfrankiswork@netscape.net>
dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Fri Feb 14 17:40:59 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 52212
Amy asked:
> Interesting. The movies have decided she isn't working-
class . . .
> any take on whether this is supported by canon? (In the US the
> answer would be a clear yes, with two professional parents, but
class
> is different here.) As for where she comes from, haven't a clue.
> Are you saying you don't see any other indications that she's from
> London?
Having two professional parents is a pretty strong indicator here,
too. Being called Hermione is another, IMO. It's not yer average
Sarf Landan name. Going to France for a vacation is mildly
indicative.
Now I come to think of it, we *do* have a character (possibly two)
who IIRC uses questions as part of his normal pattern of speech:
Stan Shunpike (I will try and check). Hermione is worlds
away: 'I 'ad me teef fixed by that Madam Pomfrey, dinnoi?' isn't her.
Hermione may well be a Londoner, but she's not that sort of
Londoner, IMO. She is not so much rootless as traceless in her
origins.
I suppose I ought to take comments on movie!Hermione to the movie
list.
David
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive