Time Travel in POA

eillim022861 <the.harrisfamily@virgin.net> the.harrisfamily at virgin.net
Thu Jan 2 23:54:16 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 49119

'annemehr' states
>Even more problematic to me is, how could you end up killing your 
>past self? If you do, you don't survive to use the time turner, so 
>you don't go back to kill yourself, so you *do* survive, so...or 
>else the universe implodes, but it couldn't have, because there's 
>Hermione saying that loads of wizards have killed their past selves

My view

I have to admit that I have always had a problem with time travel in 
POA.  One theory that I have read about (apologies if this has been 
covered already)is the existence of parallel universes where a 
different you or me exists, but is leading a slightly different 
life.  The argument goes that if you went back in time and killed 
yourself, you would in fact be killing yourself from a parallel 
universe, not your own.

I'm not sure if this adds anything to the debate or confuses the 
issue any more.

eillim






More information about the HPforGrownups archive