How would Harry have killed Sirius in PoA?
hedge2staxy <hodgins@ssi.net>
hodgins at ssi.net
Mon Jan 13 03:19:16 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 49708
Here we are--that suspenseful moment in Chapter "Cat, Rat, and Dog"
of PoA. Harry has recovered his wand in a scuffle and is now
preparing to end Sirius Black's life. A combination of Crookshanks
and Lupin, stop us from seeing if Harry would have killed him, but
then I started to wonder. How?
I guess if you layered enough hexes onto a person you could kill him
or the easy Snape way out would be to immobilize Black and let the
dementors do the rest. Somehow, though, neither of these meshes with
the spirit of the scene and as a 3rd year at Hogwarts, Harry really
wouldn't have had the sophistication to do anything more than this,
would he?
Any theories as to what might have been on the tip of Harry's
tongue? Perhaps, we're not supposed to think this far, and the
moment is just to convey the depth of Harry's anguish at the loss of
his parents.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive