[HPforGrownups] Re: Hagrid and Voldermort

[IAmLordCassandra at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 49754


> 
> Alex:  
> But what if Hagrid was just holding it from the
> night he picked up Harry when LV went down at the
> Potters house? He didn't actually use it. What if
> in POA Peter Pettigrew was "hiding" in Hagrids
> house because Hagrid had LVs wand there in his
> home. Peter wanted to steal LVs wand.  Why else
> would he be in Hagrids hut? 

Cassie:  Ahh..I hadn't thought of that possibility before. I agree with you. It's a fantasic theory ^^ But this leads me to other thoughts. If Hagrid did have Voldemort's wand, how did Voldemort get it later on?(Wormtail? Fake!Moody?) And what did Hagrid do when he found it missing?  And what's more, how would Wormtail know to look in Hagrid's Hut? Him having Voldemort's wand probably wouldn't be such well know news. Perhaps he heard it whilst spying?  
> 
> Cassie (me) wrote:
> Though...I do wonder if he has his own wand.
> After all, after seeing what 
> happened with Ron's broken wand you'd think
> Hagrid's wouldn't work so well. 
> 
> Alexandra:
> We know it does not work well.  In PS/SS he tries
> to turn Dudley into a pig and only manages a
> tail.  He uses a crossbow in COS to answer the
> door not his pink umbrella. So, maybe he knows it
> does not work well.  The pink umbrella is Hagrids
> wand.  I do not doubt that.  Rowling gives
> outrageously obvious clues. It was on the back
> wall when he engorged the pumpkins... he used it
> in PS/SS moving the boat, going into Diagon
> Alley. 

Cassie:  

So you agree that it *does* work well at times? I'm simply saying that if Hagrid had only half a wand or even a whole wand put back together by some means (I would think that it wouldn't be the easiest thing to put a wand back together. After all, they wouldn't bother breaking them when a person was expelled/committed of a crime/whatever if the wand could easily be put back together. Unless they're aren't nice and don't let other people keep the parts of their wand, like Hagrid ^^)  

As for the Crossbow reference...well, the fact that Hagrid isn't supposed to have a wand at that time would make it rather strange if he came to the door pointing it at someone (even stranger considering it's in his umbrella ^^;)  

~Cassie-who thinks she thinks to much...I think XP~ 

Musashi: Nandakanda to kikare tara
Kojirou: Kota ete ageru ga yo no nasake
Musashi: Sekai no hakai wo fusegutame
Kojirou: Sekai no heiwa wo mamorutame
Musashi: Ai to shinjitsu no aku o tsuranuku
Kojirou: Raburii Chaamii na kataki yaku
Musashi: Musashi!
Kojirou: Kojirou!
Musashi: Ginga wo kakeru Roketto Dan no futari ni wa
Kojirou: Howaito Horu shiroi ashita ga matteru ze
Nyaasu:  Nya, Nya-n te na