more speculation

[Debbie McLain <debmclain@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 49898

Snuffles srsiriusblack at a... wrote:
> After having been kept fully awake in thought on our newly released 
lines... 
> What if Dumbledore is actually James' father or grandfather. - The 
latter 
> more likely as to age. To protect Harry from thing which he may not 
have been 
> ready to understand in DD eyes, he may not have told Harry. Harry's 
return to 
> the Dursleys for protection would have kept Hogwarts completely 
safe- as DD 
> would have rationalised. DD is the only wizard of whom V. was ever 
> frightened, yet Harry is the one who sent him into a bodiless 
existence. 
> Perhaps the strength of DD lies in Harry.  
> DD has always been a paternal figure to Harry- even more so than 
Sirius or Remus who played paternal roles. 

Me:

DD can't be Harry's grandfather. In the beginning of SS/PS, 
McGonagall never says she's so sorry DD's son was killed. And in 
fact, DD says himself "I've come to bring Harry to his aunt and 
uncle. They're the only family he has left now." Family includes 
anyone even remotely related to you.

I think Voldy killed all the Potters over time, and I mean ALL - at 
least the ones still left over from V's ancestor's not killing them. 
After all, they are the heirs to Gryffindor, which means they are 
the "official" fighters of evil. Okay, okay... it's all theory, but 
I'm pretty much convinced I will be proven correct in OoP.

Harry is the last one, the one the entire WW is counting on to save 
them. That's what DD has to tell him (besides the other messy stuff 
about his parents, of course). Hmmm... starting to sound like "The 
Matrix"...

-Debbie
who screamed and stopped making dinner to check the internet when her 
husband of all people gave her the news in an "oh, yeah, by the 
way.." tone.